The investigation you have been given
Nothing. The fieldwork question is on this page.
- The fieldwork question written in your own words
- Two sub-hypotheses, each with its null
- The syllabus topic and sub-topic you are investigating
- A prediction you can defend, and the reasoning behind it
Everyone has the same question. Almost none of the marks are for the question.
You were handed the question and you collect the data as a group. That is allowed. The parts that make the report yours come later.
How do the fluvial characteristics of a river change with distance from the source?
Your report states it word for word, then names your river: the Asse at Nyon. Criterion A (Fieldwork question and geographic context) also wants a precise location attached to it: that is step 2.
| Criterion | Marks | Shared with the class, or yours? |
|---|---|---|
| A · Fieldwork question and geographic context | 3 | Shared question. Your map, your framing |
| B · Method(s) of investigation | 3 | Methods you are given. Your justification of them |
| C · Quality and treatment of information collected | 6 | Yours |
| D · Written analysis | 8 | Yours |
| E · Conclusion | 2 | Yours |
| F · Evaluation | 3 | Yours |
Nineteen of the twenty-five marks are earned after the fieldwork day. Criteria C to F are written alone, from a shared dataset. Two people with the same readings can end up several grades apart.
Everything below is how we suggest you actually do it.
Put the question in your own words
Rewrite the question as a sentence you would say out loud. If you cannot, you do not yet know what you are measuring.
Fluvial characteristics are the measurable properties of the channel and its flow: width, depth, wetted perimeter, gradient, velocity, the size and shape of the load. Not the scenery, land use or wildlife. Change is what you are looking for.
Distance from the source, in metres, is the x-axis of every graph of a variable along the river. Not site number: that is an arbitrary label and throws away the spacing between your sites.
Stating the question on page one and never returning to it. Criterion D (Written analysis) asks whether your analysis lets the question be answered, and Criterion E (Conclusion) whether your conclusion answers it. Keep asking: so, how do the characteristics change with distance?
Write two sub-hypotheses, and their nulls
Break the question into two sub-hypotheses (our rule): testable claims that together answer it. Two gives the analysis, the conclusion and the evaluation their shape; three or more spreads 850 words too thin to explain anything.
A usable hypothesis is directional (it says which way), links two measurable variables, and could turn out false. "Velocity will increase with distance from the source" qualifies. "The river changes downstream" does not.
Write the null hypothesis beside each: there is no relationship between the two variables. It is what a statistical test lets you reject. A test is optional (step 4), but write the null either way.
"The River Asse follows the Bradshaw model."
Several claims at once, so no result can confirm or contradict it cleanly.
"Cross-sectional area increases with distance from the source." Null: there is no relationship between cross-sectional area and distance from the source.
One relationship, two measured variables, a direction and a null.
Using models well, Bradshaw included
A model supports your understanding of geographical theory: the understanding earns the marks, and the model explains nothing on its own.
The Bradshaw model says discharge, width, depth and velocity increase downstream, while bedload size, channel roughness and gradient decrease. Use it for the overall picture, but it is a summary of a tendency, not a cause. The top band of Criterion D (Written analysis) wants each pattern explained from its mechanism.
"Velocity increased downstream, as the Bradshaw model predicts."
Names a model and stops. Shows no understanding of why.
"Manning's equation predicts that velocity can rise with hydraulic radius even where the gradient falls. Where hydraulic radius rose between two sites, velocity should rise with it; a site where it did not has a local cause to find."
A named model, its mechanism, and a test against the data.
| Model | What it predicts | Test it with |
|---|---|---|
| Hydraulic geometry (Leopold and Maddock, 1953) | Width, depth and velocity each rise as a power of discharge; downstream, width usually rises fastest and velocity least | Width, depth, velocity and discharge at each site |
| Hydraulic radius and channel efficiency | A larger, rounder channel loses proportionally less energy to friction | Cross-sectional area and wetted perimeter |
| Manning's equation | Velocity depends on hydraulic radius, gradient and bed roughness, so it can rise downstream even as the gradient falls | Velocity, gradient and hydraulic radius |
| Hjulström curve (1935) | The flow speed needed to erode, carry or deposit particles of each size | Bedload size against velocity |
| Downstream fining (Sternberg, 1875) and attrition | Bedload gets smaller and rounder downstream | Bedload size, best as cumulative frequency curves, and Powers roundness |
| The graded long profile (Mackin, 1948) | A concave long profile, flattening towards base level, here Lake Geneva | Altitude against distance from source |
| The drainage basin system | Discharge grows with basin area and tributary inputs, and changes in steps where water enters or leaves the channel | Discharge against distance from source |
| The Bradshaw model (1978) | A teaching summary of the whole downstream picture, with no values on it | Nothing directly. Use it for the overview, then one of the models above for each variable |
It comes from a 1978 school textbook, The Earth’s Changing Surface, by M. J. Bradshaw, A. J. Abbott and A. P. Gelsthorpe. It is a teaching diagram with no axes, units or data, so “the results fit the Bradshaw model” can be neither true nor false.
A river is usually not fastest in its steep upper course. There the channel is small, shallow and bouldery: a large wetted perimeter for its cross-sectional area, so a low hydraulic radius, and a rough bed. Most energy goes into friction and turbulence.
Downstream the channel is larger and smoother, hydraulic radius rises, and mean velocity increases despite the gentler gradient. Explaining this well is exactly what Criterion D (Written analysis) rewards.
Name the syllabus link, then describe it
The investigation sits in the optional theme Freshwater, drainage basins, sub-topic drainage basin hydrology and geomorphology: river discharge and its relationship to channel characteristics and hydraulic radius, and the processes of erosion, transportation and deposition.
Naming it earns a mark. Describing it earns the band above: one more sentence saying what in that content your fieldwork examines, and why measuring these variables at these sites tests it.
Not with the hypotheses, and not with a model. The introduction is the first thing the examiner reads: set the scene on the Asse first (our rule), so the question and hypotheses arrive as questions about a real place.
Write in the third person, from the first sentence
Write the whole report in the third person (our rule): no I, me, my, we, us or our, in any section, the evaluation included. Start now: fixing it in a finished report means rewriting hundreds of sentences.
The passive is not the only way. Velocity was measured at 0.6 of depth suits a method. For a finding, make the river the subject: discharge rises downstream, not it was found that discharge rises downstream.
"We measured velocity with a flowmeter, but I think my readings at the shallowest sites might be wrong because I held it too close to the bed."
Four first-person words, and the reason offered as a hunch.
"Velocity at the shallowest sites may be underestimated: the flowmeter sat close to the bed, where friction slows the flow."
Fewer words, and the reason stated as a reason.
Design it for a screen, before you write it
The report is one PDF, marked on a screen by an examiner who has never seen the Asse. If it is not clear on screen, it earns nothing: an unreadable figure weakens every sentence of analysis that rests on it.
Decide now: one font and size for text, one style each for headings and captions, figures readable without zooming, and the same colour for the same variable in every figure.
Step 8 checks the finished PDF at 100% on screen. Design for that from the start.
It can explain hydraulic geometry, the Bradshaw model or why hydraulic radius matters, when a textbook explanation has not landed. Reading around your topic is what Level 1 is for.
It cannot write your hypotheses. A hypothesis is a claim you are willing to be wrong about, and your reasoning for it in step 6 is what earns the marks.
Ready for step 2?
0 of 11An unticked box is your next job, not a mark against you. Most take minutes.
Step 2 covers the rest of Criterion A (Fieldwork question and geographic context): where the river is, why it suits the investigation, and the locational map.
Anything marked “our river” is specific to our fieldwork on the River Asse at Nyon. Photographs are the author’s own.
