My eight-step process
Criteria E and F: Conclusion and evaluation · 5 marks · conclusion 2 · evaluation 3≈ 500 words · suggested

Conclusion and evaluation

You arrive with

A finished analysis. Both sections judge work that already exists, so write them once the analysis is settled.

You leave with
  • A conclusion that answers the fieldwork question, in numbers
  • Strengths and weaknesses specific to your investigation
  • Improvements, each with its likely effect explained
  • An honest position on how far your findings can be trusted

Two marks for a conclusion built from your findings, three for evaluating your methods, question, presentation and location.

The conclusion is short: answer the question with your data and add nothing new. The evaluation must be specific to your investigation, never generic.

Criterion E · Conclusion · 2 marks · ~200 wordsanswer it

Summarise your findings and answer the fieldwork question in one clear statement, consistent with the analysis. Quote data. Introduce nothing new.

Criterion F · Evaluation · 3 marks · ~300 wordsjudge it

Weigh strengths and weaknesses of the data collection methods, the fieldwork question, the presentation of data and the choice of location (the river, and the number and placement of sites). Suggest realistic improvements and explain what each would change.

Everything below is how we suggest you actually do it.

The conclusion: answer the question

2 min

Write it as three short paragraphs (our rule): the outcome of sub-hypothesis 1, then of sub-hypothesis 2, then the answer to the fieldwork question drawn from both. Most drafts stop after the hypotheses and never return to the question.

Open each sub-hypothesis paragraph with its verdict in one word or two: supported, partly supported or not supported. Then give the evidence that decided it.

Answer the fieldwork question directly, in numbers: name the variables that answered it, give the values at each end of the reach and the direction of change, and say whether that answers all of the question or only part.

Be honest about scope. If one sub-hypothesis was not supported, say so; reporting only the successes is not consistent with the analysis.

No new ideas. No new explanation, source or limitation. Everything here should already be argued in the analysis.

Three conclusions the data will not carry

"Discharge increases downstream, which proves the Bradshaw model." One river on one day proves no model. Write "consistent with", and account for site 9, where the downstream trend breaks.

"Site 9 must be a measurement error." Nothing was re-measured, so the conclusion cannot say this. Calling a reading an error needs the evidence from step 4 (map, photographs, field notes), not a spoiled trend.

"The renaturation works have reduced the river's discharge." One day's readings have no before, no after and no unmodified comparison, so they cannot carry a causal claim about the works.

Two more conclusion mistakes

Restating the analysis. A paraphrase of your analysis earns nothing.

Hedging. "The results were somewhat inconclusive but generally showed some change." If the data answered the question, say so.

A student guide to the independent investigation
Royal Geographical Society, free. Its chapters on conclusions and evaluation are excellent on overclaiming and generic evaluation. Written for A level, so apply it to these criteria.
Open the RGS guide

The evaluation: be specific

2 min

Human error, the weather, more sites, better equipment: true of every fieldwork investigation, so they say nothing about yours. Attach every weakness to something that actually happened.

Superficialband 1

"There may have been human error when measuring. More data could have been collected and better equipment used. The weather could have affected the results."

Could have been written before the fieldwork day, about any river.

Explainedband 3

"Wetted perimeter was measured with a tape laid along the bed, which lifted off between boulders at the upper sites where the bed is coarsest. This systematically underestimates wetted perimeter where the bed is roughest and, since hydraulic radius is area divided by wetted perimeter, overestimates hydraulic radius at the sites where the analysis claimed it was lowest, weakening the velocity explanation. A chain pressed into the bed would follow the gaps the tape bridged; re-measuring one coarse site with it would show the size of the underestimate."

Technique, sites, direction of error, effect on a specific conclusion, and an improvement with its effect.

State the direction of each error and follow it to a claim: not "this may have affected accuracy" but "this makes the number too high, at these sites, which weakens this argument".

A ready-made limitation

Geopacks quote the flowmeter at ±5% with a working range of 0.5 to 1.5 m s⁻¹ (reference in step 3). Say which sites fell outside the range, and which comparisons between sites are too close to survive ±5%.

Strengths count too

The descriptor says strengths and/or weaknesses. Real strengths: all nine sites measured on one day under the same flow, repeated velocity trials, a wide altitude range, every reading recorded independently by each group member. Say what each lets you trust.

The four targets of a top-band evaluation

1 min

Give each target a short paragraph of prose, not a table: a table lists weaknesses but leaves out the effect on the results, which is where the marks are. The evaluation comes after the conclusion, on its own page.

The data collection methods

Which technique, at which sites, in which direction, affecting which conclusion.

The fieldwork question

Easy marks, rarely taken. "Fluvial characteristics" is broad, so eight variables answer it thinly. Say how a question naming two or three variables would be sharper.

The presentation of data

Which figure did not work, and what would have shown it better? For example, a proportional-symbol map that made small values invisible.

The choice of location

Nine sites placed by public access, not systematically, with a 2.3 km gap at the top and two just 40 m apart; step 4 shows what n = 9 does to a statistical test. In the engineered reaches, distance from the source is not the only control on the channel.

The location argumentour river

For: 298 m of fall across 8.9 km, from near the source into the lower course, in one day under the same flow.

Against: the lower reaches are being reshaped by the flood-protection and renaturation scheme, so the sites that should show the clearest downstream trend are partly a design decision.

For your own investigation

Say which sites are affected and how far it reduces confidence in the trend. That beats "a longer river could have been used".

Improvements: say what each would change

1 min

The top band wants the potential impact of these improvements explained. Every improvement needs a because.

Improvement…and what it would change
A chain rather than a tape for wetted perimeterFollows the bed's roughness instead of bridging it, removing the underestimate at the coarse upper sites
Five velocity trials rather than threeA more reliable mean where flow is turbulent, and a better measure of how variable it was
Sites at fixed 1 km intervalsEven coverage, no clustered pair, and a Spearman's result not weighted towards easy access
Repeat measurements in a different seasonSeparates the downstream trend from the discharge on the day

Keep them realistic: "a gauging station at every site" is a different investigation, not an improvement.

Extending the study

An extension asks a new question. For example: compare an engineered reach with a natural one at a similar distance from the source, so human modification varies instead of distance.

Using AI at this stepLevel 1 · AI Planning

It can argue with a limitation you have already found. Describe it, say why it matters, and let the tool push back.

It cannot generate the limitations. A tool that cannot see your study will offer human error, weather and more sites: exactly what the bottom band calls "superficial, not appropriate, or not relevant".

What this level means

Ready for step 8?

0 of 17

Cross out every sentence of your evaluation that would be true of any river fieldwork. What is left is what scores.

Next, assembling it

Step 8 turns the sections into one report: word count, referencing, AI honesty and what gets submitted.

Anything marked “our river” is specific to our fieldwork on the River Asse at Nyon. Photographs are the author’s own.