My eight-step process
Criterion D: Written analysis · 8 marks≈ 850 words · suggested

Written analysis

You arrive with

Finished figures, your sub-hypotheses, and a statistical result if you ran one. Do not start writing while the graphs are still changing.

You leave with
  • Each sub-hypothesis examined in turn, and answered
  • Every pattern explained, not just described
  • Anomalies identified and explained
  • Data quoted in the prose as evidence
  • A written analysis that answers the fieldwork question

Eight marks, nearly a third of the IA, for explaining, not describing.

Almost everybody can describe what a graph does. The higher bands ask why it does it, and the top band asks you to account for the parts that do not fit.

1 · The theory
What should happen, and why

State what the theory predicts for this variable and give the mechanism: not "Bradshaw predicts velocity increases" but why it does. Step 1 lists a model for each variable.

2 · Your findings
What did happen, with numbers

Describe the pattern with figures from your data: values, the range, the correlation coefficient, whether it is significant.

3 · The explanation
Why yours agrees or differs

The marks. Where your river follows the theory, explain the mechanism at work here. Where it doesn't, explain what about this river caused that.

Open each part with its sub-hypothesis, stated in full as a heading, then run the three moves; after both, answer the fieldwork question. Most reports skip move 3, and that is the difference between the middle bands and the top one.

Move 1 comes before any number. A section that opens with a correlation coefficient reads as a maths exercise; one that opens with what the Asse should do, and why, reads as geography.

Everything below is how we suggest you actually do it.

Describing versus explaining

3 min

A description says what the graph does: direction, size, where it changes. You need it, but on its own it caps you in the middle bands.

An explanation says what caused it, through a mechanism, in this river. If your sentence would be true of any river anywhere, you are still describing.

A structure, not a sentence to copy

Model sentences show what a good sentence does and in what order. Yours must be built from your own data and written entirely by you.

Descriptionbands 3–4

“Discharge increased with distance from the source. This supports the Bradshaw model and the hypothesis.”

Linked to the hypothesis, and it stops where the marks start. It would be true of almost any river.

Explanationbands 7–8

“Discharge rose from [your value] m³ s⁻¹ at site 1 to [your value] m³ s⁻¹ at site 8, as the hypothesis predicted, then fell by [your percentage] to [your value] m³ s⁻¹ at site 9, only 200 m further downstream. The rise is what a larger, smoother channel predicts: as hydraulic radius increases, proportionally less water touches the bed and banks, so less energy is lost to friction. The fall is not consistent with that, and 200 m is far too short for the downstream trend to reverse, so the cause must lie at site 9 itself rather than in distance from the source.”

Figures as evidence, a named mechanism, and the anomaly tied to a hypothesis and a place. Which feature of site 9 is responsible is deliberately left out: that is your work.

A named mechanism for bedload

Bedload is the variable most often described and least often explained. Attrition and abrasion wear stones smaller and rounder the further they travel.

The Hjulström curve links velocity to the particle sizes a river can erode, transport and deposit, so a fall in velocity predicts what the bed is made of. Trace your own velocity readings onto it: the flowmeter manual reproduces it in section 3.3 (linked in step 3).

Where is the Asse?

Every explanation should name something about this river: a site, a reach, a bridge or weir, the renaturation works, the geology, the land use. A paragraph that never mentions the Asse or a place on it is a maths exercise, however correct its numbers.

Show the places you explain from: a photograph of the site, an aerial view from the photospheres (step 2), a cross-section on a map. Evidence of the place is evidence for the explanation.

A test for every sentence

Ask: could this have been written before the fieldwork? If yes, it is theory or description. If it needed your numbers, sites and river, it is analysis. A strong analysis is mostly the second kind.

Discuss the river, not nine sites in a row

1 min

Do not organise by site. A paragraph per site gives nine descriptions and no argument, because the question is about change along the river.

Organise by sub-hypothesis: each gets its three moves, using whichever sites are relevant. Then draw them together to answer the fieldwork question.

Use one variable to explain another. Cross-sectional area and velocity together make discharge; hydraulic radius links channel shape to velocity; bedload size is evidence of the energy the other variables describe.

A workable shape for 850 words
Sub-hypothesis 1: theory, findings, explanation. ~325 words
Sub-hypothesis 2: theory, findings, explanation. ~325 words
The anomalies, explained. ~100 words
Drawing it together: what all of this says about the fieldwork question. ~100 words
Don't save the answer for the conclusion

Criterion D (Written analysis) asks whether the analysis lets the fieldwork question be answered; Criterion E (Conclusion) asks whether the conclusion is supported by it. A judgement that first appears in the conclusion loses marks in both.

Explaining the site that does not fit

1 min

When a site sits off the trend, work through four possibilities and say which you think it is. Explain it; never delete it.

A measurement problem

The tape lifted, the rule sank into silt, the float caught an eddy. Say so here; the detail belongs in the evaluation.

A local channel condition

A pool sampled as a riffle, a bridge fixing the width, a bend concentrating flow on one bank.

Human modification

An engineered, straightened or restored reach, where width, depth and gradient are partly a design decision. The strongest explanation available on this river.

A catchment change

A tributary raising discharge, or a change in geology or land use altering what the river carries.

Then name it specifically. "Site [n] lies in a reach straightened and held between engineered banks" is an explanation. "Human activity may have affected this site" is not.

Why this river is good for anomaliesour river

The Asse is straightened in places, confined in others, and about 4.5 km inside Nyon has been under a flood-protection and renaturation scheme since 2019, built in stages. A simple distance-from-source model should break down here in places you can identify.

For your own investigation

Check every anomalous site against what has been done to the channel there before calling it error. Explained, it lifts you to 7–8; only listed, it leaves you at 5–6.

Our advice

Quote your data in the prose

3 min

The top band wants no gaps in the supporting evidence: numbers in your sentences, not only in your figures. "Discharge rose steadily" is an assertion. "Discharge rose from [your value] m³ s⁻¹ at site 1 to [your value] m³ s⁻¹ at site 8" is evidence.

Quote selectively: the endpoints, the range, the correlation coefficient and its significance, the value at an anomalous site. The graphs and appendix carry the rest.

Refer to each figure by its number, ideally in brackets after the claim it supports. A figure never cited here does no work.

Round to what the equipment can justify: a tape read to the nearest centimetre does not support an area to four decimal places.

r², and why the leftover matters

On a scattergraph with a line of best fit, add r² (one tick box in the Excel or Sheets trendline options).

Read it as a percentage: r² = 0.68 means 68% of the variation in y is accounted for by x, and 32% is not. Your anomalies live in that leftover: “Distance from the source accounts for [your r², as a percentage] of the variation in [your variable], so something site-specific accounts for the rest.”

r² describes a straight-line fit: it is not Spearman’s rank and carries no significance test. Report whichever you ran. A high r² is still only association; the mechanism makes it geography.

A test was never compulsory

The boxes below apply only if you ran a test (see step 4). A test that is irrelevant or wrong puts you in the 3–4 band. Without one, describe patterns with real figures and spend the words on explaining.

Do not show the working

Leave out the arithmetic, formula and rank-by-rank calculation. Show the decision trail: which test and why, the statistic, n or degrees of freedom, the critical value or p, one- or two-tailed, the significance level, the verdict on the null hypothesis and what it means for the hypothesis.

A rank table or contingency table goes in an appendix: no data tables in the body.

Spearman’s or chi-squared

Spearman’s rank tests whether two variables rise or fall together: velocity or discharge against distance. Chi-squared tests whether counts in categories differ from chance, such as bedload roundness upstream against downstream.

Chi-squared needs an expected frequency of at least 5 in nearly every cell. Thirty stones across six Powers classes will not give that, and an invalid test puts you in the 3–4 band. Merge the classes first: 1–3 (angular), 4 (sub-rounded), 5–6 (rounded), or into two, and justify it in a sentence.

Use raw counts, never percentages or means, and state the degrees of freedom: (rows − 1) × (columns − 1).

Reporting a statistical result

Three clauses, in order: the coefficient, whether it is significant, and what that means for the null hypothesis.

"Spearman's rank on velocity against distance from the source gave rs = [your value] with n = 9. The critical value at the 95% level for a one-tailed test is 0.60, so the result [is / is not] significant and the null hypothesis of no relationship [can / cannot] be rejected."

With nine sites a non-significant result is likely. Stated plainly and discussed, it costs nothing; leaving it out does.

Calling a correlation weak, moderate or strong needs a source: say whose scale you are using and cite it. The critical value, not the adjective, decides whether it is significant.

Using AI at this stepLevel 0 · No AI

It can do nothing here. If a concept has not landed (how hydraulic radius affects velocity, what a correlation coefficient means), understand it before you open this section, at the levels in steps 1 and 4.

It cannot interpret your results. Explaining the pattern in your own data is the eight marks.

What this level means

Ready for step 7?

0 of 15

Write this section first and redraft it last. If you run short of time, run short somewhere else.

Next, concluding and evaluating

Step 7: a conclusion that answers the question and an evaluation specific to your investigation.

Anything marked “our river” is specific to our fieldwork on the River Asse at Nyon. Photographs are the author’s own.