The whole mark scheme
All six criteria and 25 marks in one place, so you can see where you are heading and check a draft against the whole thing in one pass.
Each criterion is also explained, in detail and with examples, on the step that teaches it. The bands below are the same words you will find there.
Fieldwork question and geographic context
Taught in step 1, the investigation you have been given and step 2, know your river.
Criterion A (Fieldwork question and geographic context) covers steps 1 and 2: the question and syllabus link here, the context and locational map in step 2.
| 1 | 2 | 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The link to the syllabus | not made, or not appropriate | an appropriate link is identified | the link is described |
| The question | not a question, too broad, or no location | geographical, with a specific location | geographical and focused, precise location |
| The map | none, or inappropriate for the question | a copy of an existing map, too much unnecessary detail or missing conventions | one or more maps following mapping conventions, with clear information and detail |
Identifying the syllabus link is a mark; describing it is the top band. The difference is one or two sentences.
Criterion A (Fieldwork question and geographic context) again, the same three marks as step 1. This step covers the location and the map.
| 1 | 2 | 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Location | no location, or too broad | a specific location identified | a precise location, clearly identified |
An unedited screenshot is "a copy of an existing map": the middle band. The top band comes from what you add to the map, not from a better basemap.
Method(s) of investigation
Taught in step 3, the fieldwork.
Two strands, three marks. Both strands must reach a band for the report to sit in it.
| 1 | 2 | 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The methods | listed or outlined, too general or vague to collect enough relevant data | described, outlining how the data is relevant to the question | described, explaining clearly and accurately how the combination of data is relevant. May describe statistical tests, if appropriate |
| The techniques | listed or outlined, and not correctly used | used correctly, allowing sufficient data, but may be minimal or only one or two variables | used correctly, resulting in reliable and good quality primary data supporting a relevant analysis |
Notice how the combination of data is relevant: why measuring these things together answers the question. Width and depth are two numbers; width, depth and velocity together give discharge.
Quality and treatment of information collected
Taught in step 4, your dataset and step 5, presenting it.
Criterion C (Quality and treatment of information collected) covers the data (this step) and its presentation (step 5).
| 1–2 | 3–4 | 5–6 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The information | mostly not relevant, or not sufficient, to address the question | most of it relevant, allowing partial analysis | all directly relevant, and sufficient in quantity and quality for full analysis |
The presentation strands of the six marks for Criterion C (Quality and treatment of information collected).
| 1–2 | 3–4 | 5–6 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Presentation | presented in a way that is inappropriate, or does not allow analysis | presented in ways appropriate for the data type | a sufficient range of the most appropriate techniques, used effectively |
| Conventions | do not follow conventions, or contain frequent errors | conventions followed, with occasional errors | graphs, tables, diagrams and illustrations follow conventions |
"Conventions" means every figure numbered in order and titled, every axis labelled with its variable and its units, every source acknowledged.
Numbering by section is fine too (our suggestion): Figure 3.2 is the second figure in section 3, the analysis. Each section starts on a new page, so a figure that moves between drafts renumbers only its own section. Pick one scheme and use it throughout.
Written analysis
Taught in step 6, written analysis.
Eight marks, four bands. Watch the verbs climb along the “Trends and patterns” row.
| 1–2 | 3–4 | 5–6 | 7–8 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Techniques | not all appropriate to the data and question | appropriate; any statistical techniques used are irrelevant or contain errors | descriptive and statistical (if appropriate to the question), appropriate to the data | descriptive and statistical, with confidence levels if appropriate |
| Trends and patterns | outlined, no explicit link; obvious trends listed | described and linked explicitly to the question or hypotheses | described and linked; outliers and anomalies listed | patterns, outliers and anomalies explained and linked to the question, hypotheses, theory, location and methods |
| Answering the question | allows the question to be answered descriptively | allows it to be answered, with gaps in the supporting evidence | allows it to be answered, with no or only minor gaps |
From 5–6 to 7–8, anomalies go from listed to explained. Step 4 is where you found the anomaly to explain.
Conclusion and evaluation
Taught in step 7, conclusion and evaluation.
The top band of Criterion F (Evaluation) names four targets. Most evaluations only cover the first.
| Criterion E (Conclusion) | 1 | 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Conclusion | a conclusion is formulated, partially supported by the analysis | a clear conclusion to the fieldwork question, supported by the analysis |
| Criterion F (Evaluation) | 1 | 2 | 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strengths and weaknesses | listed, mostly superficial, not appropriate or not relevant | outlined, mostly appropriate and relevant | the most appropriate and relevant ones explained, regarding the data collection methods, the formulation of the fieldwork question, the presentation of data, and the choice of location |
| Improvements | listed | outlined | outlined, and the potential impact of these improvements explained |
The bands tell you what a marker is looking for. They do not tell you how to get there, which is what the eight steps are for.
Step 8, the pre-submission check